Why Tube-Based Systems Are Essential for Electrical Panels: A Fire Engineering Perspective

In modern industrial and commercial environments, electrical panels are at the heart of power distribution. However, they also pose one of the highest fire risks due to high voltage components, overheating, short circuits, or arcing faults. To mitigate this risk, tube-based fire suppression systems are becoming a standard safety measure. Let’s explore why these systems are critical, how they work, and answer common questions surrounding their use in electrical panels.

What Is a Tube-Based Fire Suppression System?

A tube-based system, also known as a detection and suppression system, consists of a heat-sensitive polymer tube connected to a suppression agent cylinder (like clean agents, CO2, or dry chemicals). The tube acts as both a detection and delivery mechanism for extinguishing the fire, designed specifically for compact or enclosed spaces such as:

  • Electrical panels

  • Server racks

  • CNC machines

  • Industrial enclosures

Why Tube-Based Systems Are Necessary in Electrical Panels

1. Early Detection and Fast Response

Electrical fires often start small—due to overheating wires, short circuits, or component failures—but can escalate rapidly. The polymer tube detects heat directly at the source, often within seconds of a fire starting. This early intervention is critical in confined spaces like control panels where fire can spread quickly.

2. Localized Suppression

Unlike room-based suppression systems that require a sealed environment and affect the whole room, tube-based systems target the fire at its origin. This reduces damage to surrounding components and avoids unnecessary discharge.

3. No Human Intervention Needed

Once installed, tube-based systems work automatically and autonomously. They require no manual activation, making them ideal for 24/7 protection—even in unmanned or remote facilities.

4. Compact and Space-Saving

Electrical panels have limited internal space. The flexible tubing can be routed around components without obstructing operation or airflow, making it ideal for retrofit applications.

5. Safe for Sensitive Equipment

When using clean agents like FK-5-1-12 (Novec 1230) or FM-200, these systems extinguish fire without leaving any residue or damaging sensitive electronics—unlike water or powder-based systems.

6. Compliance with Fire Safety Standards

Many safety codes and regulations now recommend or require localized fire protection for high-risk enclosures. Tube-based systems help ensure compliance with:

  • NFPA 2001 (Clean Agent Fire Extinguishing Systems)

  • IS 15105 / ISO 14520

  • CE and UL Listings (depending on manufacturer)

How Does It Work?

?? Step-by-Step Process:

  1. Installation: A pressurized polymer detection tube is installed inside the panel, routed around potential fire risk areas.

  2. Detection: The tube is sensitive to heat. When a fire breaks out, the nearest section of the tube ruptures at ~100–180°C.

  3. Activation:

    • Direct System: The rupture acts as a nozzle, releasing the extinguishing agent through the hole.

    • Indirect System: The rupture triggers a valve to release the agent via a separate pipe network.

  4. Suppression: The fire is suppressed within seconds, minimizing damage and downtime.

Descriptive Comparison: Tube-Based vs. Traditional Fire Protection Systems

1. Detection Mechanism

Tube-Based Systems
Tube-based systems use a pressurized, heat-sensitive polymer tube installed directly inside the electrical panel. This tube acts as a linear thermal detector. When exposed to heat from a developing fire, the tube bursts at the hottest point—right at the origin of the fire. This means detection is fast, localized, and precise, allowing for immediate response.

Traditional Fire Protection Systems
Conventional systems rely on smoke detectors, heat detectors, or manual detection, which are usually mounted on ceilings or walls. These detectors respond only when smoke or heat reaches their sensors, which may be delayed, especially if the fire starts inside an enclosed space like a panel. This can result in slower response times and greater damage before suppression begins.

2. Suppression Coverage

Tube-Based Systems
These systems offer localized fire suppression, meaning the extinguishing agent is discharged exactly where the fire occurs. Whether it's a short circuit in a busbar or an overheating breaker, the tube system attacks the fire at its source, minimizing the spread.

Traditional Systems
Conventional suppression systems are designed to cover entire rooms or zones. They flood the entire area with suppression agent, which is not always efficient for small or enclosed fires. This approach often results in wasted agent, potential exposure risks, and unnecessary downtime.

3. Installation and Space Requirements

Tube-Based Systems
Tube systems are compact and flexible. The tubing can be routed around components within the electrical enclosure without disrupting functionality. Because of their small footprint, these systems are ideal for tight spaces such as:

  • Control panels

  • Electrical cabinets

  • Server racks

Traditional Systems
Traditional fire systems need space for detectors, piping, and nozzles, typically installed throughout the room. They also require structural modifications for effective installation, including false ceilings, pressurized agent cylinders, and dedicated agent storage rooms in some cases.

4. Speed of Response

Tube-Based Systems
These systems detect and suppress fires within seconds of ignition, often before the fire becomes visible externally. This rapid response significantly reduces equipment damage and downtime.

Traditional Systems
There is often a delay between detection and suppression, especially in room-based systems. The agent must reach a critical concentration across the entire area to be effective, which can take several seconds to minutes, depending on the system and room size.

5. Type of Agent Used

Tube-Based Systems
Typically utilize clean agents (like FK-5-1-12, FM-200), CO2, or dry chemicals, depending on the application. Clean agents are ideal for electrical equipment since they are:

  • Non-conductive

  • Non-corrosive

  • Leave no residue

Traditional Systems
Traditional systems may use water sprinklers, foam, CO2, or dry powders. Water and powder are not suitable for electrical equipment due to the risk of short circuits, corrosion, and residue damage.

6. Automatic Operation

Tube-Based Systems
Operate completely autonomously, with no need for electricity or human intervention. This is especially useful in remote, unmanned, or critical systems that require 24/7 protection.

Traditional Systems
Require a control panel, power supply, and often human verification or alarm response. They are not as suitable for quick, localized suppression without external triggers.

7. Post-Fire Clean-up and Downtime

Tube-Based Systems
When using clean agents, there’s minimal clean-up required. Systems can be reset quickly by replacing the tube and refilling the agent cylinder, reducing downtime and operational losses.

Traditional Systems
Can require extensive clean-up—especially if water or powder is discharged. Sensitive equipment may need complete replacement, and facilities could experience lengthy shutdowns.

8. Cost and Maintenance

Tube-Based Systems
These systems are generally cost-effective for protecting specific assets (like panels) compared to full-room systems. Maintenance involves regular visual inspection and pressure checks, which are simple and quick.

Traditional Systems
Can be more expensive to install, particularly in retrofits. Maintenance is also more involved—requiring detector calibration, piping inspection, and periodic agent replacement on a broader scale.

Final Thoughts

In fire engineering technology, the goal is not just to suppress fires—but to do it efficiently, safely, and without unnecessary damage. Tube-based fire suppression systems excel at protecting high-risk, confined spaces like electrical panels where speed, precision, and safety are critical. While traditional systems have their place, they are not optimized for localized, enclosed fire sources.

For businesses and facilities relying heavily on uninterrupted power and automation, tube-based systems provide a targeted, modern, and compliant solution for fire risk management.

FAQ: Tube-Based Fire Suppression in Electrical Panels

Q1: What types of extinguishing agents are used in tube systems?

A: Common agents include:

  • Clean agents like FM-200 or FK-5-1-12

  • CO2 for non-occupied spaces

  • Dry chemicals for industrial use

Q2: Are tube-based systems safe for use in live electrical panels?

A: Yes. Clean agents used in these systems are non-conductive, non-corrosive, and safe for use on energized electrical equipment.

Q3: Do tube-based systems need power to operate?

A: No. These systems are mechanical and do not rely on electricity, making them functional even during a power failure.

Q4: How often do tube-based systems need maintenance?

A: Typical maintenance involves visual inspection and pressure checks every 6–12 months, as recommended by the manufacturer and fire safety codes.

Q5: Can these systems be refilled or reused after discharge?

A: Yes. Most systems are rechargeable. After a fire or accidental discharge, the tube and agent cylinder can be replaced or refilled.

Conclusion: A Smart Investment in Fire Safety

Tube-based fire suppression systems are no longer optional—they are a smart, efficient, and often regulatory-compliant way to protect electrical panels. Whether you manage a data center, industrial plant, or commercial building, this technology provides peace of mind by safeguarding critical systems from devastating fire incidents.

You can contact us on the details Given Below

Request Call Back.

Want to know more about our products.. fill the form below

Enquire Now